Your Sales Commission Plan May Reward the Wrong Deal

Before criticizing a salesperson for the quality of a deal, read the sales commission plan. If it rewards booked revenue without distinguishing margin, payment terms, or commercial risk, start by questioning the instructions.

Would your plan pay the same commission on two equally sized contracts if one required a customer deposit and the other required your business to fund the entire job? If so, is that an intentional choice or simply something nobody considered when the plan was written?

My concern is not that every commission must wait until every dollar is collected. It is that the incentive plan should reflect the kind of business the company wants to win.

Two Contracts, One Commission, Different Cash Commitments

Consider two contracts. Each has a selling price of $2,000,000 and expected variable delivery costs of $1,500,000. In this example, a 5% commission is paid at booking, producing a $100,000 payment and leaving $400,000 after those delivery costs and commission, before fixed overhead and other costs.

The payment terms differ:

  • Contract A: The customer pays a 30% deposit, or $600,000, before work starts.
  • Contract B: The customer pays nothing until after delivery.

Assume each contract requires $800,000 of delivery spending before the next customer receipt. Including the upfront $100,000 commission, the initial cash requirement is $900,000.

For Contract A, the deposit reduces the amount the business must provide to $300,000. For Contract B, the business must provide the full $900,000.

The planned contribution is the same before financing costs. The initial funding requirement differs by $600,000, while the salesperson receives the same $100,000.

That does not prove Contract B is a bad deal. It shows that the commission formula does not distinguish this aspect of deal quality, so another part of the approval process must.

Decide What Sales Can Actually Control

I would start with authority, not with a new formula. List the commercial decisions salespeople can make and the decisions reserved for management.

If a salesperson can offer discounts or extend payment terms, make the consequences visible in the deal review. If the owner approves those concessions to win a strategic account, do not later pretend the salesperson alone created the cash exposure.

Apply the same discipline to collections. A customer who will not pay because the invoice is wrong or the product is defective presents a different accountability question from a salesperson promising unauthorized terms.

Sales, operations, and finance need separate responsibilities that fit together. Making the salesperson responsible for every downstream failure is not a substitute for fixing the process.

Choose the Sales Commission Plan Mechanism That Fits the Problem

There is no need to turn a small-company sales commission plan into an actuarial exercise. I would evaluate three approaches before choosing one.

  • Revenue commission with commercial boundaries: Keep the formula simple, but require approval for discounts, unusually long terms, or credit exposure beyond defined limits.
  • Contribution-based commission: Reward the value left after clearly defined costs, provided the costing is reliable and the salesperson can understand the calculation.
  • Staged payment: Consider paying commission at agreed events, such as booking and customer receipt, with clear treatment of delays, cancellations, credits, and responsibilities.

These are design options, not a recommendation to combine every mechanism. A plan that takes an hour to explain may obscure the behavior it is supposed to encourage.

Write down when commission is earned, when it is paid, and how exceptions are handled. Obtain appropriate employment and legal review before implementing changes. Do not assume existing agreements permit retroactive withholding or claw backs.

Test the Plan Against Actual Deals

Before changing anything, review ten recent contracts. Put the incentive calculation beside the commercial outcome and ask:

  • Margin discipline: Did discounting or scope concessions undermine the value the plan rewarded?
  • Cash terms: Did the salesperson have an incentive and authority to negotiate better terms?
  • Accountability: Were adverse outcomes caused by sales decisions, management approvals, delivery failures, or billing problems?
  • Payout clarity: Could the salesperson have calculated the expected commission before closing the deal?

Then model the proposed approach on the same contracts. Look for unintended rewards and penalties before asking the team to work under it.

The Goal of a Sales Commission Plan

The objective is not to find a clever way to pay less commission. It is to pay confidently for business that meets the company’s commercial and financial needs.

Keep the promise made under the existing plan. Improve the next plan so that winning for the salesperson and winning for the business point in the same direction.

Book a call with Business CFO for Hire to test your sales commission plan against your last ten contracts.

Share this:

About the Author

Stan Alhadeff, fractional CFO and author of Run the Business Don't Become It, featured in Atlanta Business Journal Leaders in Finance

Stan Alhadeff is the founder of Business CFO For Hire and one of the longest-serving independent fractional CFOs in the U.S. With 30+ years of financial and operational leadership spanning startups to $1B+ enterprises, he's guided companies through fundraises, ownership transitions, rapid growth, and M&A across a dozen-plus industries. He's also the author of Run the Business, Don't Become It, a field guide to financial clarity for founders and CEOs. Based in Atlanta, Stan works with growing businesses nationwide.

SIGN UP

Business CFO Insights Newsletter